Medical Device Design Education Identifying Problems Through Observation and Hands-On Training

Main Article Content

Jules Sherman, MFA Henry C Lee, MD Madeleine Weiss Alexandria I Kristensen-Cabrera


Experiential learning, which may include hands-on learning paired with observation and reflection, has been applied in several industries; however, the impact of experiential learning in design education is not well known. We investigated how the type of simulation-based learning could affect the acquisition of knowledge and the ability to synthesize that understanding into insights that can contribute to medical design innovation. One workshop included observational learning and the other experiential learning with hands-on training. Each course consisted of 14-16 multidisciplinary undergraduate and graduate students. During both workshops, we measured student comprehension of two procedures-- infant resuscitation and management of maternal hemorrhage.  We focused on the first two phases of design thinking: “Understanding” and “Defining the Problems”.  Although the course focused on “medical device design”, we encouraged students to look beyond the tool to imagine how their design change could impact the entire system in which the tool was utilized. We did not find a significant difference between the scores given to students in the two courses by industry experts. Although the quality of the ideas and execution were similar between both workshops, the instructors noticed that the integration of hands-on training into the second workshop created a higher level of excitement in the class. In order to understand the impact of observational learning versus hands-on training at a deeper level, both workshops could be expanded into full quarter classes that allow students to expand their design thinking skills to prototype and test their ideas in the real world. 

Article Details

How to Cite
SHERMAN, Jules et al. Medical Device Design Education. Design and Technology Education: an International Journal, [S.l.], v. 23, n. 2, p. 154-174, july 2018. ISSN 1360-1431. Available at: <>. Date accessed: 18 june 2019.